My sister sent me a message this morning. She'd been going through my father's papers (so many papers!) and she found a rather long poem I'd written for him for his birthday. I was 20 year old. I had enormous respect for my dad and it came through, in verse. What he accomplished in his life, especially given the time and place where he lived, the paucity of opportunities, and the political quagmire in postwar Poland -- it was truly extraordinary. And he did it without fawning, cheating or losing sight of his principles. He remains the second youngest ambassador to the United Nations in the history of that organization (he was appointed to that position just shy of his 34th birthday), and he immediately fell into an even higher position upon arriving in New York -- Poland was at that moment a member of the Security Council and he stepped into that role at a time of geopolitical tensions as African states sought their independence from colonizing nations. My father developed a reputation for being a bridge builder, despite coming from a communist state. He was seen as highly articulate and intelligent. A well liked pragmatist. (These are not my observations -- you can read much of this in the archives dating to the 1960s.) This is why he was later appointed as the Under Secretary to the United Nations.
But he was not a family man. Restless, private in his thoughts, immersed in politics, trying to survive in a climate that doomed most. He liked his two daughters just fine, but he never really connected with either my sister or me. He just didn't care about the trivial daily grind that seemed to be our lot, as we built our own families and working lives. He was an especially lousy grandfather, claiming a love for his grandkids but never reaching out to them, especially mine who lived on the other side of the ocean. Never asked about them, never send cards or letters, never called. If I volunteered some story, I could tell his mind was elsewhere. Didn't really listen, which I attributed to not really caring, though in retrospect, I think that's too harsh. Both my father and my mother cared. From a distance.
When my father left his final UN post, he did not want to go back to work for the Polish government (the year was 1982) and so he retired. He was just 56 years old. Between that, his complete disenchantment with my mother (leading to multiple shenanigans with women in his orbit), and his increasingly heavy drinking, he, to put it bluntly, lost it. He lived his senior life, all thirty years of it, with his girlfriend, drank heavily, and this calm bridge-building father of mine turned into a ranting crazy man. In his final decade, I visited him annually, and I don't think I ever saw him when he didn't have alcohol on his breath. I took from that that he needed to drink to face me.
I've written about my mother more on Ocean, because I took over her care as she aged her way out of independent living into assisted living, and finally to a nursing facility. My father died a more lonely man. My sister was living and working in Sweden, his friends were either dead or off doing things that did not include seeing him. His girlfriend was much younger and found him to be annoying, so she spent most of her time with her own friends and colleagues, and more often than not, chose to stay in her own flat in Krakow (he lived in Warsaw). Even at 100, my mother still had friends in Poland, California and Madison. And she had me. I gave her my listening ear every day and let her talk sometimes for just 10 minutes, sometimes for ten times that.
Both my parents had this in common: despite everything, they did not die happy. My mother believed her life had been one hellish struggle. My father wondered if having conversations and churning out paper all his days could be called a meaningful life.
In recent weeks, this thought keeps bugging me -- were both my parents victims of a seismic shift in attitudes toward the older generation? I was already backing away from the model of a daughter who would be a servant to the wishes and needs of her elders. I remember discussing this with a colleague from Japan who said she never had wanted children because between her career ambitions and attending to the demands of her in laws, she simply hadn't the time for anything else. That wasn't me! I didn't jump around either parent ever, and if I took care of my mom in her most senior years, it was never going to be a round-the-clock kind of thing. Nor did she want me that close to her -- she was not physically affectionate, or in need of proximity to her kids. She chose to live far away from both, until she couldn't hack it anymore and I brought her back to Madison, kicking and screaming.
Just this last week, Ed pointed me to question/answer kind of article in the New York Times. Here, I'll gift it for you -- it's this one. The title says it all: My Adult Daughter Has Gone 'No Contact' With Me. What Should I Do.
The daughter had offered to care for her mother round the clock after some medical procedure, but there had been an outburst, the mother said stuff that was harsh. She later apologized, but her daughter said nope, not enough. No more contact. Mom suggested joint counseling. Daughter said -- I dont have time. I'll reconnect once YOU get counseling. So, what do you think the esteemed NYT columnist said? I think he followed pretty much the conventional thinking these days: adult children do not have to put up with what they may consider to be toxic relationships with their parents. They need to think first about their own mental health and their own family needs. Yes, the mother should do therapy. Even though she thinks she had a fine relationship with her daughter -- this is probably only her fantasy. "No contact" is almost always the result of years of mistrust and dissatisfaction. The mother needs to get help examining her own behaviors toward the adult daughter.
What was interesting to me was that this was the obvious solution, even though the mother's letter was brief and offered very little information on, well, anything. I think no advice should be given on a topic so complicated, spanning generations -- both within that particular family unit and, too, in the broader historical context.
In my view, you should (as a parent of a grown child, or as a grown child of a parent) always tred carefully, keep judgment to yourself, avoid hurting the other, acknowledge that you are not living the same lives and that each of those lives deserves respect. So, I'm a middle grounder! No contact, toxic relationships -- these are common labels now, but to me, they summarize poorly what's really going on. And what's going on is that we would really love, as adult kids, to have kind, giving, helping parents that remained interested, especially in our children, but respected the fact that we have limited time for them and would prefer if they kept their opinions to themselves and shared our political religious and cultural beliefs. And as parents, we would like to have adult kids who are respectful, grateful, sharing, affectionate, understanding of our aging struggles, and sometimes just a little helpful. That is a perfect mismatch and when the going gets tough, conflicts will bubble over, and in the end, given our stressful lives, we're all going to be torn apart more often than not, and maybe that's a good thing, but I doubt it. I'm glad I never pulled a "no contact" with my mother. She did it to me and it was shocking and hurtful and lead to nothing better. My sister and I couldn't be the people she wanted us to be, but I'm glad I tried until the end, to enter each conversation, really each and every conversation -- with hope.
*. *. *
Yes, we had that frost. Just a degree or two below freezing, but it counts.
My basil died, but my nasturtium, being very close to the house, survived. So, just a degree or two below, and depending where you stood for the night.
But the sunshine! Cool outside still, but hey, some of the flowers are still with me...

The sun comes into the house beautifully, streaming in through the windows! I didnt get much sleep last night and I woke up too early and too tired. I looked at my face in the mirror (I have to put in eye drops four times a day) and it looks like the face of a person who has forgotten to use any face creams for the past twenty years. I dont know why it's so drawn. Well, no matter. The sunshine puts me on a good path for the day. Still, I am tired.
(with a garden rose...)

The day is very pleasant. I play with Millie in her yard...

While she expresses herself through her zoomies, I snip off spotted rose leaves (the fungus struck at least half of my roses and I am resisting treating it with anything other than a manual clean up, snipping of the damaged leaves). We both really like our time in her yard, even though the positioning of the sun is such that the place remains mostly in the shade. On a cool day, you need to keep movingto stay warm.
And speaking of movement, Ed finally convinced me to go back to the park with him. He'd wanted to go with me to the Brooklyn Wildlife Area, where the hike is longer and harder, but I begged off. Too tired, and as I told him, that's a dedicated hunting area and I hate walking through the woods and hearing all that November gunfire.
Millie stays home to rest. while he and I revisit our favorite local park. The walk is just fabulous. All that sunshine of course...

But, too, being on familiar ground, walking a path that's so loved by us -- it's really uplifting.
And at home, Millie and I study roses (well, I study roses, she studies me). I watch my crime drama, then play my Mozart, remembering that my mom, too, loved Mozart. She gave up on any music in her last years. Maybe this was why she found it so difficult to get through them.
with so much love...
















































